Creative has just launched some their latest products. One of them is the X-Fi Xtreme Audio. Some rumours say that this X-Fi Xtreme Audio is not a real X-Fi. Is that true? I don’t know since I haven’t checked the card with my own hands and eyes. Photos below are taken from Creative’s website.
I got this picture from Creative’s website.
The X-Fi Xtreme Audio (click photo below for larger view):
The “old” Audigy SE (click photo below for larger view):
Not really a same card, but let’s check the chipset.
They share the same chipset? Audigy SE (black PCB) is not X-Fi for sure, but how about this X-Fi Xtreme Audio (blue PCB)? It brings X-Fi name but without the X-Fi chip (it uses same chip with Audigy SE)?
Below is the real X-Fi chipset (see the different, it’s CA20K1!): This is the “giant” processor with huge amount of transistors and outstanding processing power. The “old” chip doesn’t have such capability.
I think Creative shouldn’t trick the consumer by providing X-Fi logo on card which has no X-Fi chip inside. Yes perhaps they can emulate the X-Fi software to run on this old non X-Fi chip, but how about the performance? I heard that this card has no hardware acceleration. Well, Creative and X-Fi is well known for its gaming capability. Without it, I will not buy X-Fi for sure.
Most users outside there are expecting explanation from this problem.
Added 21 Januari 2007:
I have discussed this things with a person from Creative. He admitted that the Xtreme Audio doesn’t use the CA20K1. And in the future, “X-Fi” logo will become Creative’s trade mark for high quality sound. No matter what’s the chipset inside. So, from this moment, we can expect a lot of “X-Fi” logo and device from Creative mixed with and without the CA20K1 inside. I guess the price can be used as the simplest method to identify whether you will have the CA20K1 or not inside the device. The lowest on the rank should be the X-Fi Xtreme Music. If you see an X-Fi with price lower than this, expect to find it without CA20K1.
About the sound quality? Only your ears can be the judge 😀
deddy
February 16, 2007 21:55sir, i would like to ask some questions.
IF in that case, Xifi audio using the same chipset as CODED : CA0106 – XXX
Could my Sound blaster live 24bit, which has the same chipset, moded in to Xi Fi Audio ?
Jimmy Auw
February 17, 2007 12:00I haven’t test the X-Fi Audio yet, so can’t comment…
But usually, you can’t mod it until you can change the hardware ID…
deddy
February 17, 2007 13:41do you have the link?
i looked for it, but can not find it yet
All i found was modding from audigy2 to audigy4
But soundblaster live 24 bit has a spec that almost the same with xifi audio don;t you agree with me?
Jimmy Auw
February 18, 2007 02:07The problem is if you have different hardware ID, you simply can’t install the X-Fi driver on other card…
deddy
February 20, 2007 20:09can i change the hardware id?
deddy
February 21, 2007 21:29compare to Philips Aurilium 805, which one has better sound quality?
Philips VS X-Fi audio Vs X-fi music
Jimmy Auw
February 22, 2007 15:21X-Fi Extreme Music is far better than the X-Fi audio or Philips.
dirtfarmer
October 9, 2007 08:52i got this reply from Creative Americas Customer Care , when i complain about Sound Blaster X-Fi Xtreme Audio b een noting more the a rework Audigy SE
her what there told me
The X-Fi Xtreme Audio does have the X-Fi technology, but the chipset is different than the other cards. For the best experience I would recommend the X-Fi Xtreme Gamer Fatality Pro Series. The X-Fi Xtreme Audio is still a high quality soundcard. Please contact us if you need any further assistance.
yudhidono
May 7, 2008 23:50hallo that good
Anonymous
May 11, 2008 13:02i buy X-Fi Xtreme Audio, DSP chipset is “CA0111â€.not “CA0106â€
http://www.4gamer.net/review/x-fi_xtreme_gamer/img/12.jpg
rZero
June 11, 2008 01:01In reference to the CA0111 vs CA0106 question, I might guess that it could be exactly the same chip with different numbers stamped onto it by Creative to attempt to end any question whether or not these two cards are the same except for Hardware ID and Drivers. Take this into consideration: the SB0410 (Live 24-bit) is the same thing as the Augigy SE. And it sure does look the same as the X-Fi Xtreme Audio (except for color).
Some more information….
Model: SB0410
* P17 Chip: CA0106-DAT
* AC97 Codec: None
* ADC: WM8775EDS (4 Channel)
* DAC: CS4382 (114 dB, 24-Bit, 192 kHz, 8-Channel D/A Converter with DSD Support)
* SPDIF Out control switches between Mic in and SPDIF out.
—The DAC (Cirrus Logic CS4382) is of very high quality on this card. See http://www.cirrus.com/en/pubs/proDatasheet/CS4382_F2.pdf
I own a SB Live! 24-bit and it is by far one of the best sounding cards I’ve heard for compressed music playback. Gaming performance, however, is just okay. Maybe that’s why they call this other card in question a “X-Fi Xtreme ‘Audio'”, because they know it’s also great for the same things as the Live! 24-bit (audio quality), thus proving its basically the same card. I really do wonder if there are any real differences at all, besides hardware ID. It’s an audio-quality card, not a card you would want to offload CPU-required tasks. Kind of misleading. Could be considered false advertising. If you want to offload your CPU from having to do so many sound-related tasks, get a card w/ the CA20K1 chip or something from another company. I’m just glad I own the one that cost $30 instead of $70. It’s gotta be the same card…. ***naughty creative labs***
rZero
June 11, 2008 01:12ACTUALLY if you look diagonally to the top-left of the P17 (CA0106) chip, I see another difference. If you look there on both cards you will see 2 smaller chips on each. Both look similar on the SB0410 (audigy/live 24bit), but on the X-Fi Xtreme Audio, 1 of the 2 chips looks like it has pins on all 4 sides instead of on 2 sides. Maybe this little chip is the difference? I have no idea what it does…anyone else? Maybe its a different DAC, ADC, Codec, …? Still, does this difference justify a $40 price difference?
rZero
June 11, 2008 01:32Sorry for not containing this into one post….
Looked at my card. It’s a SB Live 24-bit. It’s black like the Audigy SE, BUT, it has the chips just like the X-Fi Xtreme Audio. And that chip I spoke of that is different, it’s the CS4382 that apparently is on the SB Live 24-bit but NOT on the Audigy SE…hmmmm
I think I figured it out….here’s my guess:
The X-Fi Xtreme Audio is a re-named SB Live! 24-bit (which creative no longer sells), and the Audigy SE is actually a completely different, lower quality card. So they took the card I own, changed its name and changed it from a $30 to a $70 card. And then they introduced the Audigy SE around the same time which apparently does not contain the high-quality CS4382 DAC and is probably cheaper to make, which they now sell for $30. So it’s not false advertizing…it’s just marketing. Perhaps their cost of making the SB Live! 24-bit was exceeding the profits and that’s why they did this?
monica
July 23, 2008 09:28i just want to know how xtreme audio works in my audio system. i have used this soundcard for a year.. maybe i have not tried over xtreme audio yet, so i dont know about clarity boom treble etc….after i had read ur blog and read the minus of my sc , i have a plan to change my soundcard. i need ur recommendation for better sc…i like music n movie ,i have any option. which sc do u choose? extreme music or extreme gamers fatal1ty?
Thanks for answer
Jimmy Auw
July 23, 2008 22:12Hi,
Both will be ok for you.
Thanks.
William Chong
August 4, 2008 17:16Hi, Jimmy,
I am from Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, I have visited your sites and found
some useful informations about audio. This time, I would like to learn
somethings from you.
My friend has bought an onkyo SE90 PCI card to fix to his PC, he uses
PC as a digital sources for his Audio system ( Mingda Integrated
Vacuum Tube Amplifier and Sonus Faber Bookshelf Speakers.)
He can’t find a good CD player below RM4,000-00 to his system, that’s
why he uses PC as his CD player.
He told me that the SE90PCI is 24bit/192 output, but I saw the box
stated something like 24/192 only available by using the Optical /
digital output and Not the Analoque RCA output. But We don’t really
understand because the manual and box are all in Japanese language. Can you
kindly let us know about this matter ?
He bought this card because of the two RCA analoque output, so he can
connect to his Amplifier using good Interconnect Cable directly.
We also need your advice about the SE200 PCI, does this pair of RCA
analoque output is 24/192 ? we are confused.
Finally looking forwards for your reply soon.
Thank you for your time.
Best Regards,
William Chong.
KL.
Jimmy Auw
August 4, 2008 21:01RM4000? You have a lot of option at this price range and surely better than your PC as source.
SE200 is better than SE90.
All digital output from any sound card basically capable to output bit/frequency as high as their DSP capability. So, if you DSP (on this case, the VIA Envy24) supports 24/192, then your digital out should be able to output at the same number to. But please be noted that you need this high bitrate/high frequency source (like DVD, DTS-CD, or specially recorded audio file, etc). If you are playing the standard music (all MP3 and CD-Audio), the output will be 16/44.1. No matter you are using digital out or analog out.
You have the option to resample the analog out to higher bitrate/sample rate by using resampler software (like SSRC plug-in on Foobar Audio Player). But I dont think this will bring significant improvement.
Thank you.
William Chong
August 5, 2008 18:52Thank you Jimmy for your prompt reply.
How about if we converted my CD Audio files using Nero software to save in my harddisk as 24/192 format, and I play the converted audio (24/192) directly from my hard disk, does the output is 24/192 ? ( Digital or RCA output connector).
Can you kindly recommend any good software that can convert my 16/44.1 audio files to 24/192 ?
For your information, our malaysia audio distributor always sell their branded CD player too much overpriced compare with other countries. Even Singapore is ,more reasonable.
Thanks for your time.
William Chong.
Jimmy Auw
August 5, 2008 21:18Hi,
You could visit Singapore to buy it then 🙂
I don’t think it’s useful enough to convert your CD Audio to 24/192. It’s almost the same like pouring a glass of water to a big pail. The volume of the water itself is still the same, right?
When you play your 24/192 via analog out, the result is analog (no bit/digital information). It’s just you software player will recognize it as 24/192 materials. If you play with digital out, you have to make sure that you have DAC with 24/192 capability. Otherwise, you will not be able to hear it.
You can use Foobar Audio Player and active the SSRC plugin to resample to 192 kHz.
Thanks.
KainXS
August 9, 2008 01:41Guys, I don’t think you know this but their are drivers now that allow the Audigy SE to run as X-Fi Xtreme Audio’s, you can find them on the techpowerup forums
and yes with the crystalyzers
William Chong
August 15, 2008 15:33Hi Guys,
How to install the SSRC Plug-in to my FooBar2000 ?
Thanks.
Jimmy Auw
August 15, 2008 21:35I think it’s one of Foobar’s default component…
TheDukeSD
October 9, 2008 10:43Audigy SE to X-Fi Xtreme Audio (1.04.0079 modded drivers)
Daniel K was the first one that modded the X-Fi Xtreme Audio drivers for Audigy SE. The last X-Fi X-treme modded for Audigy SE are 1.04.0078.
What I did? I modded the 1.04.0079 X-Fi Xtreme Audio drivers for Audigy Value, Audigy SE / Audigy 2 SE, Audigy LS, Live! 24-bit .
More information you can find here: http://forums.techpowerup.com/showthread.php?p=1006208
What you gain? You will have the same sound on Audigy Se like on X-Fi Xtreme Audio.
[b]Drivers modded for Windows XP 32 bit and 64 bit:[/b]
Main site – http://rapidshare.com/files/151893417/Audigy_to_X-Fi_Extreme_Audio_1_04_0079_XP_Vista_4_1.rar.html
Mirror 1 – http://depositfiles.com/files/8593275
Mirror 2 – http://www.zshare.net/download/2023999379688368/
Mirror 3 – http://uploaded.to/?id=mdijz0
Mirror 4- http://rapidshare.de/files/40641625/Audigy_to_X-Fi_Extreme_Audio_1_04_0079_XP_Vista_4_1.rar.html
– Driver for Windows Vista 5.12.1.2007 / Windows XP v5.12.01.621
– APO Interface Module 2.06.00
– Audio Console 2.40.14
– Console Launcher 2.40.09
– Host OpenAL 1.00.14
[b]Driverele modate pentru Windows Vista 32 bit and 64 bit:[/b]
Main Site – http://rapidshare.com/files/151896076/Audigy_to_X-Fi_Extreme_Audio_1_04_0079_XP_Vista_4_2.rar.html
Mirror 1- http://depositfiles.com/files/8593896
Mirror 2 – http://www.zshare.net/download/20242342abc3b91b/
Mirror 3- http://uploaded.to/?id=5d4qfw
Mirror 4 – http://rapidshare.de/files/40641765/Audigy_to_X-Fi_Extreme_Audio_1_04_0079_XP_Vista_4_2.rar.html
– Driver for Windows Vista 5.12.1.2007 / Windows XP v5.12.01.621
– APO Interface Module 2.06.00
– Audio Console 2.40.14
– Console Launcher 2.40.09
– Host OpenAL 1.01.08
The modded drivers were tested by me on XP 32 bit, XP 64 bit, Vista 32 bit si Vista 64 bit. The worked nice.
Vinx
April 20, 2009 08:16I am one of Creative’s fraudulent trick’s prey, if I ever knew X-fi Xtreme Audio is not a true X-fi, I would never buy it.
gochancu
June 16, 2009 11:47Hi, I can’t understand how to add your site in my rss reader. Can you Help me, please 🙂
NICK
June 16, 2009 19:53I just take a look inside of my sound card , x-fi extreme audio.And i removed the X-FI sticker from the top of the chip.This is what i saw
http://img23.imageshack.us/img23/6548/picture9c.th.jpg
This is the chip CA0111.I Googled it and i found this from creative
http://www.creative.com/oem/products/chips/ca0111.asp
So its like an mid end x-fi and not the high end version of the chip CA20K2
NICK
June 16, 2009 19:55Sorry this is the right image size
http://img23.imageshack.us/img23/6548/picture9c.jpg
SAM
June 20, 2009 08:46guys just keep this in mind and you’ll be alright.
the x-fi extreme gamer pci. (black box with green stripes.)
is the lowest cheapest real x-fi card. all other cards that cost less are not x-fi no matter whats written on it.
even the usb 5.1 surround external card is a fake x-fi.(still beat the crap out of most basic adapters.)
monster wave
September 2, 2009 03:31any body know wat chipset inside usb 5.1 surround external SB???
some says no chipset at all inside thats box ??
Elvia Fiorito
September 20, 2009 03:02Entscheidend insght am Ende dort nicht verlassen, es als ‘wir
wisconsin union theater map
October 25, 2010 15:17This was a really good writeup by you looking forward to visit more very soon.
Finz Isamu
April 8, 2011 14:32Thank You Very Much For Your Help
беÑплатные фильмы онлайн Ñмотреть беÑплатно, беÑплатные фильмы онлайн Ñмотреть
October 25, 2011 01:46Тут подобран большой аÑÑортимент интереÑных фильмов онлайн
конÑалтинговые уÑлуги, СПб, Санкт-Петербург, бухгалтерÑкое обÑлуживание
November 5, 2012 19:04БухгалтерÑкое обÑлуживание под заказ в г С-Петербург
Google
July 28, 2014 02:51* A sitemap to navigate your website is helpful for visitors
to access main pages. Based on their experience, they could know how much is required before going into details.
But it seems Memorial Day wasn’t important
enough to Google.
Anonymous
October 26, 2015 21:25TOP personal
Anonymous
October 27, 2015 15:03ÐšÐ¾Ð¼Ð¿Ð°Ð½Ð¸Ñ Proffy Service
Anonymous
October 28, 2015 14:00Оккультные практики
Anonymous
October 31, 2015 13:52СтоимоÑÑ‚ÑŒ ÑÑ‚Ñжки пола за квадратный метр
Anonymous
November 4, 2015 16:28Форум Zverolov
Anonymous
November 4, 2015 20:19Купить Ñаженцы в Санкт-Петербурге Спб ЛенинградÑкой облаÑти оптом